[C&C] Rock Quarry Landscape - 4 different versions

Discussion in 'Photo Critique' started by john m flores, Aug 29, 2014.

  1. john m flores

    john m flores All-Pro

    Aug 13, 2012
  2. grebeman

    grebeman Old Codgers Group

    My initial thoughts suggest that the subject is better suited to a landscape format. For me numbers 3 and 4 render too dark on my monitor for the foreground, however I prefer the more dramatic sky rendering of either 3 or 4, I'd try and couple that with the foreground (by which I mean up to and including the tree line) tones of number 2.

  3. Luke

    Luke Super Moderator Subscribing Member

    Nov 11, 2011
    Milwaukee, WI USA
    I like the color palette of #1, #1 or #2 for the composition/crop, and #3 for the darkness and grit.

    I'd probably crop #3 to be closer to the first two (the trucks and buildings don't do much for me, and I feel like the roads lead the eye into the scene) and drop some control points on the trees to brighten them up while keeping most of the scene dark and industrial looking. Also, I like the pops of yellow on the trucks in the first....I would integrate that aspect as well.
  4. pdh

    pdh Legend

    Jan 2, 2011
    For me the most potential is in #4, although the conical roofs and blue buildings mar the clean white horizontal of the road that would otherwise work nicely with the dark horizontals of the quarry terracing in the upper mid right
    Have you tried flipping it? It reads a bit better even with those buildings still there.
    I'm with Barrie on landscape format - in fact I might stretch it to 16*9

    I find the processing sets my teeth on edge a bit in colour, to be brutally honest; I'd be backing off the contrast; I expect you've tried it in black and white?

    I dunno, I always feel a bit weird about this sort of request. We can all suggest how we'd do it, but we're not you John ... if you're asking us the question, then is it also worth asking yourself have you selected the right shot to go with?
  5. ivoire

    ivoire All-Pro

    Dec 3, 2011
    chicago burbs
    I'd go with #1 for colors and darken the sky 50-60% and the processing plant/area 30%
  6. CiaranReilly

    CiaranReilly Rookie

    Dec 3, 2013
    I prefer #1, like square but would let more in on the left hand side, those tanks/buildings are too close to the edge in my opinion. Cool shot though, would look well printed large

    Sent from my iPhone using SeriousCompacts mobile app
  7. Jock Elliott

    Jock Elliott All-Pro

    Jan 3, 2012
    Troy, NY
    I like the bottom one . . . for the sky.

    Cheers, Jock
  8. Luckypenguin

    Luckypenguin Hall of Famer

    Dec 24, 2010
    Brisbane, Australia
    I don't generally go for square crops but the first two images works best in terms of overall framing and composition. The first seems to have a bit too much clarity or similar processing applied and a level of saturation that doesn't appear to match the light conditions. I don't know if it's a dust spot or not but I'd clone out that dot just at the top of the treeline.